Skip to content 
The world’s most dominant creative software company and its subscription exit penalty
When Adobe switched from selling software outright to a subscription-only model in 2013, it was one of the most controversial pivots in tech history. Designers, photographers and creative professionals who had paid for perpetual licenses suddenly found themselves renting software indefinitely. Eleven years on, the model has only become more aggressive, with companies implementing stricter terms and increasing subscription fees, which has frustrated many users.
The issue I want to focus on today isn’t the subscription model itself — businesses are entitled to charge how they choose. What concerns me, as a commercial lawyer, is the cancellation penalty. Specifically, I am concerned about the fact that many consumers are unaware of this penalty until they attempt to leave.
The Early Termination Fee Nobody Told You About
If you sign up for an Adobe Creative Cloud annual plan — the cheapest way to access the full suite — you are entering a twelve-month contract. So far, so reasonable. What is less reasonable is what happens if you need to cancel before the year is up.
Adobe charges an early termination fee of 50% of the remaining contract value. So if you sign up in January, pay for three months, and then cancel in April, you will owe Adobe 50% of the remaining nine months’ fees. On a full Creative Cloud subscription at around £54.99 per month, that could mean a cancellation penalty of over £247.
The question is: did you know that when you signed up? For most people, the answer is no. The fee is disclosed in Adobe’s terms of service, but those terms run to thousands of words, and the fee is not prominently flagged during the sign-up process.
The US Regulatory Response
In 2023, the US Federal Trade Commission launched an investigation into Adobe’s cancellation practices, alleging that the company made it unreasonably difficult for consumers to cancel subscriptions and failed to adequately disclose the early termination fee. This wasn’t a fringe complaint — it reflected a widespread consumer experience.
In the UK, the position is governed by the Consumer Rights Act 2015, which requires that contract terms be fair and transparent. A term that imposes a substantial financial penalty for cancellation is arguably unfair within the meaning of the Act if that penalty is not clearly communicated at the point of sale.
The Interface Design Problem
Adobe’s sign-up flow is a masterclass in what regulators call ‘asymmetric disclosure’. Adobe prominently and attractively displays the benefits, which include access to Photoshop, Illustrator, Premiere Pro, and dozens of other tools. Most users rarely read the small print containing the commitment and cancellation penalty.
There’s also a design element to the cancellation process itself. Getting out of an Adobe subscription requires navigating multiple screens, being presented with retention offers, and in some cases waiting on hold for a customer service agent. The process is, by design, effortful. That effort is intentional — every additional minute of friction increases the chance that the consumer gives up and stays subscribed.
What the Law Says
Under the Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013, traders must provide clear information about the total cost of the contract before the consumer is bound by it. They must also make the cancellation process as straightforward as the sign-up process.
There is a strong argument that Adobe’s current practices fall short of these requirements — at least for consumers. Business customers have a different legal position, and if you signed up through a company account, your options may be more limited, potentially affecting your ability to negotiate terms or seek recourse compared to individual consumers.
The Practical Position
If you’re stuck in an Adobe contract and want out, start by contacting Adobe’s customer service and asking explicitly about your cancellation rights. If you signed up within the last 14 days, you have an automatic right of withdrawal under the Consumer Contracts Regulations. Should the cancellation penalty remain unclear after 14 days, you possess the right to contest it.
Document everything. Keep screenshots of the sign-up flow if you have them. If Adobe refuses to waive the fee and you believe it wasn’t adequately disclosed, you can raise the matter with your bank, file a complaint with Trading Standards (the government agency that enforces consumer protection laws), or pursue a claim in the small claims court.
The broader lesson is this: before you sign up for any annual subscription, search specifically for the cancellation policy. Don’t assume you can leave whenever you want. The company writes the terms with the intention of keeping you in payment.
At Lawdit Solicitors, we advise on commercial contracts, consumer rights, and subscription disputes. If your business uses Adobe or similar subscription software and you have questions about your contractual position, visit info@staylegal.co.uk
